Truths Untruthed
In 1906 and 1907, William James, the Harvard psychologist turned philosopher, delivered the lectures later published as ‘Pragmatism.’ Their message was simple: ideas are tools for finding one’s way, not doctrines to which the world must conform. A map’s claim to accuracy rests on more than its appearance. It must guide the traveler reliably through the territory.
James asked for an idea’s ‘cash-value,’ i.e., the concrete difference its being true would make in experience. His target was intellectualism, the habit of treating an abstract answer as the end of an inquiry rather than its beginning. For him, an idea must prove a dependable guide as experience accumulates to become true. In other words, truth is what works ‘in the long run and on the whole.’
Economic intellectualism never tires of dispensing truths. Whether it was US tariffs, the closure of the Strait of Hormuz, or China’s exported deflation, the refrain was the same: the global economy could not escape a sharp slowdown. Each warning had a valid economic argument behind it. The trouble begins when the argument becomes a verdict before events have had their say.
It turns out that global activity has held up much better than expected in 2026. Truths have been untruthed .
The spirit of the macroeconomic SWOT is Jamesian: grounded in evidence, attentive to colliding forces, and open to revision. In fact, the edition earlier this year ('Fat Tails') was already in need of a refresh.

As James put it, ‘we have to live today by what truth we can get today and be ready tomorrow to call it falsehood.’



Comments